In the absence of Mohamed Salah and Roberto Firmino, they would have been most likely to say Sadio Mane, Virgil van Dijk or maybe even Xherdan Shaqiri.
But it is highly unlikely they would have plumped for a player who had never scored for Liverpool in Europes premier club competition at that moment.
However, come the end of an incredible 90 minutes, it was Origis name being chanted around Anfield, with the Belgian scoring twice to help the Reds claim the 4-0 victory they needed to progress into the Champions League final.
Having also netted a late winner against Newcastle United three days before, Origis standing with the Liverpool faithful has never been higher and it raises an intriguing question as to what manager Jurgen Klopp is going to do with the unlikely saviour this summer.
Before injury struck regular centre forward Firmino it seemed clear that Origi, alongside fellow striker Daniel Sturridge, would leave the club in the upcoming transfer window.
But, in the absence of the Brazilian, Origi has proved his worth to Klopp with a series of important goals and excellent performances.
He followed up his outstanding evening against Barcelona with another top class display against Wolverhampton Wanderers on the final day of the Premier League season and he has surely done enough to earn his place in the squad next season.
The evidence is there: Klopp no longer needs to bring in another striker as back-up to Firmino.
It has seemed obvious all season that the German coach would look to add more firepower to his squad this summer but now the need for a new forward is not necessary.
Sturridge will certainly be leaving, but Klopp has already revealed he plans to promote talented youngster Rhian Brewster next season, meaning the Englishmans replacement has already been found.
With Firmino secured as the clubs first-choice central striker, Klopp would have to try and find a forward, happy to spend most of the time on the bench, who is better than Origi.
If the 24-year-old continues to play as he has been in the last few weeks, that will be hard to do.
Liverpool are not a side with unlimited funds and they would surely be grateful of the opportunity to save some funds by not signing a player they do not need, so they can focus on other positions where they do require some improvement.
Despite having the best defence in the league this season, a new centre back partner for Van Dijk is needed while they could also do with bringing in an attacking midfielder, similar to that the quality of Nabil Fekir - who they attempted to sign last summer. James Milner being their highest scorer from midfield says it all.
By keeping Origi they may well be able to bring in better players in those two positions, making them a stronger team come the start of next season.
A fully-fit Firmino, supported by a rejuvenated Origi and the exciting Brewster will make Liverpool a dangerous attacking prospect once more and that is not to mention the threat from Golden Boot winners Mane and Salah.
Klopp does not need to go searching for another forward, as with Origi playing like this he already has everything he requires in the striking department.